Home › Doctors › Ohio › Pickerington › Primary care doctors
Primary care doctors who accept Medicare in Pickerington, OH
CMS lists 28 clinicians in this specialty with a practice address in Pickerington. Accept Medicare assignment (the Medicare-approved amount as full payment): 28. Offer telehealth: 15.
Typical amounts Medicare approves in ZIP 43147 (2024 Medicare rates, the latest CMS has published): a new-patient visit $126, of which you pay about $32; a follow-up visit $96, of which you pay about $24 — the 20% coinsurance after the yearly Part B deductible. Clinicians who don't accept assignment can charge up to 15% more; with a Medicare Advantage plan, your plan's copay applies instead.
Is this your organization or practice? Feature it at the top of this page — $49 for 30 days →
Order: clinicians who accept assignment first, then by MIPS score (highest first), then by last name.
Lucas D. Beeley, DO
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentMIPS score (2024): 80/100✓ TelehealthGraduated 2006 · Lake Erie College of Osteopathic Medicine, ErieMaleOther offices in Pickerington: 1Drug and device company payments (2025): $102Zachary D. Carpenter, DO
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentMIPS score (2024): 80/100Graduated 2021MaleKenneth O. Cayce IV, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentMIPS score (2024): 80/100Graduated 1999MaleMichael J. Frerick, DO
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentMIPS score (2024): 80/100Graduated 2021 · Ohio University, College of Osteopathic MedicineMaleDonald C. Lemay, DO
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentMIPS score (2024): 80/100✓ TelehealthGraduated 2000 · At Still University of Health Sciences, College of Osteo Med, KirksvilleMaleOther offices in Pickerington: 1Drug and device company payments (2025): $58William C. Nace, DO
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentMIPS score (2024): 80/100Graduated 2020 · Ohio University, College of Osteopathic MedicineMaleNaseeb G. Shaheen, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentMIPS score (2024): 80/100✓ TelehealthGraduated 2018 · JC Edwards School of Medicine, Marshall UniversityMaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $357Ryan Siegel, DO
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentMIPS score (2024): 80/100✓ TelehealthGraduated 2011 · Lake Erie College of Osteopathic Medicine, ErieMaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $58Mitchell Stelzer
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentMIPS score (2024): 80/100Graduated 2016 · Lake Erie College of Osteopathic Medicine, ErieMaleOther offices in Pickerington: 1Drug and device company payments (2025): $8,660Matthew J. Sullivan, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentMIPS score (2024): 80/100Graduated 2021 · Medical College of OhioMaleCaleb T. Wagner, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentMIPS score (2024): 80/100Graduated 2010MaleRahma A. Anchimbon, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentGraduated 2015FemaleJames A. Barnes, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignment✓ TelehealthGraduated 1996 · Ohio State University College of MedicineMaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $786Lisa A. Burns-Serrano, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentGraduated 1991FemaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $1,129Melissa A. Falcon, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignment✓ TelehealthGraduated 2015FemaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $55Chelsea J. Fazekas, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignment✓ TelehealthGraduated 2016 · Ohio State University College of MedicineFemaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $48Charles Fisher, DO
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentGraduated 2012 · Lincoln Memorial University Medical DepartmentMaleKatherine T. Graebel, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentGraduated 2022 · Medical College of WisconsinFemalePeter M. Martin, DO
✓ Accepts Medicare assignment✓ TelehealthGraduated 1985 · Ohio University, College of Osteopathic MedicineMaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $33Meghan K. O'Grady, DO
✓ Accepts Medicare assignment✓ TelehealthGraduated 2016 · Ohio University, College of Osteopathic MedicineFemaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $55Michael Poland
✓ Accepts Medicare assignment✓ TelehealthGraduated 1990 · Ohio State University College of MedicineMaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $76Alexander Reiner, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentGraduated 2013 · University of Cincinnati College of MedicineMaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $709Sarah J. Sbita, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignment✓ TelehealthGraduated 2011 · Northeastern Ohio University College of MedicineFemaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $300Jacob C. Schultz, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignmentGraduated 2020 · University of Toledo College of MedicineMaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $693Robert E. Sears, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignment✓ TelehealthGraduated 1999 · Ohio State University College of MedicineMaleOther offices in Pickerington: 1Harkiran Singh, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignment✓ TelehealthGraduated 2012MaleLisa H. Warner, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignment✓ TelehealthGraduated 2011FemaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $109Joseph S. Winchell, MD
✓ Accepts Medicare assignment✓ TelehealthGraduated 2002 · Ohio State University College of MedicineMaleDrug and device company payments (2025): $526
Before you book
This list comes from Medicare's enrollment records, not from reviews. Call the office to confirm the clinician is taking new Medicare patients. With Original Medicare, a clinician who accepts assignment can only charge you the Medicare deductible and coinsurance; one who doesn't may charge up to 15% more than the Medicare-approved amount. If you have a Medicare Advantage plan, check that the clinician is in the plan's network.
The MIPS final score (0–100) comes from Medicare's Merit-based Incentive Payment System for 2024. It combines quality measures, cost, improvement activities and use of certified health records, and it sets a payment adjustment. Clinicians who report as a group share the group's score. It is not a patient rating, and many clinicians have no published score.
Payments from drug and medical device companies come from CMS Open Payments (2025 general payments: meals, travel, consulting and speaking fees, gifts and similar), summed for each clinician. Receiving payments is legal and common and does not mean a clinician did anything wrong.
Other specialists in Pickerington
- Nurse practitioners90
- Cardiologists8
- Orthopedic surgeons10
- Neurologists8
- Gastroenterologists9
- Optometrists6
- Podiatrists4
- Urologists7
- Therapists and counselors9
- Physical therapists25
- Chiropractors6
- Gynecologists12
- General surgeons6
- Neurosurgeons4
Other care in Pickerington
Hospitals · Nursing homes · Dialysis centers · Home health agencies · Hospices
Nearby cities
- Canal Winchester24
- Reynoldsburg121
- Groveport6
- Gahanna65
- New Albany68
- Columbus1,001
- Lancaster54
- Grandview Heights8
Enrollment, addresses and scores are as reported to CMS and can change. This is not a list of in-network providers for any Medicare Advantage plan, and it is not medical advice. Source: CMS Provider Data Catalog — Doctors and Clinicians National Downloadable File, Clinician MIPS Performance 2024 and Facility Affiliation Data (released Oct 2, 2026).